Who Is Behind a Mysterious Election News Site in Toronto?

On Oct. 5, Daniel Tate, the executive director of IntegrityTO, shared a link on his X (Twitter) account to an article on an obscure new website called The Gritty, at thegritty.ca. Tate is running for city council in Toronto Centre, Ward 13. The piece, authored anonymously by “The Gritty Staff,” is critical of one of Tate’s main opponents, incumbent councillor Chris Moise.

Since going live on Oct. 1, the website has also made allegations against other progressive candidates, incumbents and organizations, namely Progress Toronto, while writing favourably of conservatives like Tate and Ward 14 candidate Caryma Sa’d.

Side-by-side comparison of The Grind and The Gritty website designs.

So far, no one has claimed ownership to any of the articles published nor to the website. The Gritty claims to provide “independent investigative municipal reporting covering Toronto local government, council votes, and community policy.” 

For accountability and transparency reasons, reputable media outlets provide the names of the people and the organization behind it, usually somewhere on the website. This is done in part to show that a media outlet is independent from the politicians, corporations and other groups it covers. 

Without that information provided, the question is: Who’s behind The Gritty? 

Our first lead came through the article Tate shared. The unnamed author writes that Tyler Johnson, the chief of staff of incumbent Toronto Centre councillor Chris Moise, runs a web design business outside of his role with Moise. The article says Johnson’s company is contracted by the campaigns of various local progressive councillors and candidates and thereby amounts to “double-dipping.” The article includes screengrabs of an email exchange with Johnson.  

The Grind reached out to The Gritty and to Johnson about the article.

Johnson responded by email to say that on Sept. 19, someone going by the name of Leahcim Mitchell contacted him through his company’s contact form. At the time, the person told Johnson they were “starting a human rights advocacy organization in Toronto” and wanted to “clarify pricing.” The person did not identify themselves as a reporter or representative of The Gritty.

Part of The Gritty’s article uses screencaps of an email exchange with Tyler Johnson.

Emails shared with The Grind show that Johnson replied the same day. Then Leahcim Mitchell asked about Johnson’s affiliation with Progress Toronto, an advocacy organization promoting progressive candidates in the election.

Unbeknownst to Johnson, his email answers were then published as screengrabs in The Gritty article on Oct. 1, which Tate then shared on Oct. 5.  The article claims Johnson is “running a private business while collecting a hundred thousand dollar salary as Moise’s chief of staff.” 

The Gritty provides no evidence of wrongdoing by Johnson.

Johnson told The Grind that whoever reached out to him did so “under false pretenses.” In an email, he explained that his work with “Progressive Nation takes place outside of work hours, and I handle the sales and support for our non-profit, union, and elected officials outside of Toronto.”

Johnson also shared a letter signed by Moise that allows him “to engage directly or indirectly in other work provided that it does not conflict or interfere with my duties and responsibilities as an employee of his office.”

Other articles published by The Gritty focus on Progress Toronto, the office of Mayor Olivia Chow, Toronto-Danforth candidate Sara Erhardt and urbanist Zarah Ebrahim. 

Erhardt’s campaign told The Grind that while they had received an email on Sept. 27 from The Gritty, “no reporter was identified.” The email, shared with The Grind, contained nine questions and was signed simply as “TheGritty editorial team.”

The Grind reached out to Leahcim Mitchell using the same email address Mitchell used to correspond with Johnson but received no reply.

The Grind also contacted an email address found on The Gritty’s website, which was removed from the site shortly after we sent questions about The Gritty’s origins, mission, publisher and author identities, and of any possible connections to local organizations. We also asked why their website design and name were so similar to The Grind’s. 

Ad seen on The Gritty site on Oct. 5.

Someone who did not identify themselves by name replied: “Sorry, no interest in communicating with you.”

“Leahcim” is “Michael” spelled backwards, known as an ananym, which led Johnson to believe Toronto Danforth council candidate Michael Mitchell might have a connection to the site.

We then looked at thegritty.ca’s website’s domain and saw it had been registered on Sept. 15 under Vancouver-based registrar CentralNic Canada Inc. Three days later, on Sept. 18, Michael Mitchell also registered his own campaign website — votemitchell.ca — under the same niche registrar. 

The Grind contacted Michael Mitchell to ask if he was involved with The Gritty and the article about Johnson.

Someone from “Team Mitchell” emailed back to say they had “no idea what you are talking about with regards to Leahcim Mitchell. Where did you get this information?” They also asked for a list of questions.

The Grind sent six follow-up questions including whether Michael Mitchell was the one who sent the email as Leahcim Mitchell and whether they created The Gritty‘s website.

Team Mitchell replied: “The Mitchell campaign will not respond to any of your questions in their current form, as you didn’t comply with our request in its entirety.” They then demanded screengrabs of The Grind’s correspondence with Johnson. The Grind declined.

After a follow up, Team Mitchell doubled down.

“As stated Team Mitchell will not respond until we have the information we require. If Tyler Johnson stands behind his statements show us the whole conversation. Otherwise, please do not bother us again.”

On Oct. 8, Johnson received another email from Leahcim also demanding information about “everyone you spoke to or emailed about me….what you said to each person about me … [and] copies of all emails you sent about me.”

On Oct. 13, The Gritty published another article with screengrabs of the emails The Grind had sent to Michael Mitchell. The piece claimed that Johnson had disclosed the identity of the “whistleblower” going by “Leahcim Mitchell” even though The Grind hadn’t published anything yet. It also appears there was no agreement of confidentiality between “Leahcim” and Johnson when they were corresponding.

Screencap from The Gritty website

On Oct. 17, ads began appearing on The Gritty’s website urging people to vote for Michael Mitchell.

Screencap from The Gritty website

Johnson also notes that “the website’s focus and criticisms parallel positions previously articulated by Daniel Tate and [Tate’s organization] IntegrityTO.”

So far, IntegrityTO has been mentioned in two pieces by The Gritty. One article alleges the design company of urbanist Zahra Ebrahim “has gained a number of very lucrative contracts from the City of Toronto,” using “documents released by IntegrityTO on Instagram” as its source of information. The publication also endorses Tate in an election guide page showing him as the only one in the “Should Win” and “Will Win” columns for his ward.

“In fact, when I first heard of the name ‘thegritty.ca’ I couldn’t help but notice the parallels in nomenclature,” says Johnson. (Inside “IntegrityTO” are the letters “grity.”)

Neither Tate nor IntegrityTO replied to The Grind’s requests for comment about any possible involvement with or knowledge of The Gritty. There is no evidence that Tate or IntegrityTO are involved in the publication.

X (Twitter) describes The Gritty‘s account as based in Estonia. As of time of writing, it has zero followers but is following 97 accounts, including Tate (Ward 13), Caryma Sa’d (Ward 14), Bradford and also The Grind. The Gritty’s Instagram account, which started posting on Oct. 1, has 65 followers as of the time of writing. 

Since The Grind started this investigation, The Gritty has begun explicitly endorsing Bradford for mayor on social media, but those posts are getting little to no engagement.